On The Brink Of A New Season

Photo Credit: BYU Photo

Here we are again. It's hard to believe that it has been seven months since BYU last walked off the court in Louisville. Many things have changed for the Cougars during the intervening months — and perhaps even more have stayed the same. And now we sit on the brink of yet another basketball season in Provo, ready to send our boys out to do battle with a fresh slate of hardwood foes.

In anticipation of the new year, which kicks off in earnest Wednesday night with the team's annual intra-squad scrimmage, it's time for us to take stock of what has gone down since last March, where that leaves the state of the program today, and what it means for the months ahead.

Tearful Goodbyes. While much of this year's roster is similar to the 2011-2012 squad, there were a few key departures that must be noted. Noah Hartsock has since taken his talents (and prominent bald spot) to Belgium, where I like to believe he has become Okapi Aaist's most consistently productive scorer and sleeps in a bed made of delicious waffles and exquisite chocolates. While Charles Abouo also graduated and made the jump overseas (now with Spanish second-division club Lobe Huesca), the loss of Hartsock hurts the most. Even though Abouo was clearly BYU's best, most versatile perimeter defender, that particular skill set is more easily replaceable than the type of efficient production Hartsock gave the team every single night. It was like clockwork — if Noah didn't get his 16 points and 5 boards a night, you started worrying if something might be wrong with him. That won't be an easy hole for coach Dave Rose to fill.

Report Card: Gonzaga 74, BYU 63

Brigham Young Cougars

63

Final

74

Gonzaga Bulldogs

STARTERS

	Matt Carlino, PG 7-23 FG | 3-9 3PT | 1-3 FT | 2 REB | 3 AST | 18 PTS Carlino is definitely a freshman — and that comes with its ebbs and flows. Matt carried BYU through a dismal first half offensively. However, he also forced bad shots down the stretch when he should have been feeding the red-hot Davies. Those costly mistakes may have snuffed out any possibility of a comeback, but BYU likely wouldn't have been in the game in the first place without Carlino's efforts.
	Anson Winder, SG 2-5 FG | 1-3 3PT | 0-0 FT | 1 REB | 0 AST | 5 PTS Anson didn't light the world on fire tonight, but he was solid. He played great defense and didn't turn the ball over, which is more than we can say for some people. (coughZylstracough) Winder was inexplicably nonexistent for much of the second half before Rose reinserted him in the closing minutes — where he promptly scored five points. There is a lesson in here somewhere...
	Charles Abouo, SF 4-13 FG | 1-4 3PT | 1-3 FT | 10 REB | 0 AST | 10 PTS Abouo is often simultaneously maddening and essential. He is capable of doing some of the dumbest things imaginable — and he does them frequently — but then turning around to get a key steal or grab a big rebound the next time down the floor. He made a few too many dumb mistakes tonight, but at least he rebounded and defended well. Say what you will about him, but Charles always plays hard.
	Noah Hartsock, PF 0-0 FG | 0-0 3PT | 0-0 FT | 1 REB | 0 AST | 0 PTS A sad night. No other way to put it. Courageously, Noah tried to gut it out despite playing with what looked like an artificial leg. He only lasted 7 minutes. It was abundantly clear that he just couldn't move well and was in a state of perpetual discomfort. He couldn't be effective, and the team suffered mightily as a result. Cougar fans need to hope against hope that Hartsock's sprain heals, like, now.
	Brandon Davies, C 8-18 FG | 0-0 3PT | 7-10 FT | 10 REB | 1 AST | 23 PTS After a spotty first half, Davies really turned on the jets in the second and dominated Gonzaga in the paint. As BYU made their final run down the stretch, Brandon stepped up to the plate and took over the game. It was a true "leadership moment." Of course, the guards stopped passing him the ball shortly thereafter, but we won't dwell on that. Davies was huge. (Also, he had 6 steals. Six!)

Report Card: BYU 85, San Francisco 84

Brigham Young Cougars

85

Final

84

San Francisco Dons

STARTERS

	Matt Carlino, PG 13-19 FG | 4-7 3PT | 0-1 FT | 4 REB | 3 AST | 30 PTS Obviously the star of the evening. Carlino started off hot (and I mean Jimmer hot), matching his career high with 22 — in the first half! Matt struggled reading the defense a bit in the second half, but he played solid defense (4 steals) and showed up when it counted most. While it might get overshadowed by fan anger about clock management, Carlino's game-winner was monumentally clutch.
	Anson Winder, SG 3-5 FG | 0-0 3PT | 2-2 FT | 6 REB | 2 AST | 8 PTS Winder doesn't have to score much to be extremely valuable to the Cougars. He adds plenty of value as a excellent defender who understands the game and picks his spots wisely on offense. His coast-to-coast drive (finished with a deft Eurostep move) was a thing of beauty. The decision to swap Anson into the starting five for Zylstra may be Rose's smartest of the season.
	Charles Abouo, SF 6-11 FG | 3-6 3PT | 0-0 FT | 6 REB | 4 AST | 15 PTS Oh, Charles. You got a little excited, didn't you? With time running out quickly and BYU nursing a small lead, Abouo hoisted up a few ill-advised deep balls very early in the shot clock, giving USF the extra possessions it needed to crawl back into the game. Not so good. However, Charles actually played extremely well up to that point, so I can only justify knocking him down half a grade. But if BYU had lost...
	Noah Hartsock, PF 7-13 FG | 0-0 3PT | 2-2 FT | 2 REB | 1 AST | 16 PTS This was a tough one for Hartsock. BYU shot only 9 free throws as a team the entire night, so obviously the whistles weren't going his way down low. He also had a surprising amount of trouble anticipating double-teams in the post, which I wouldn't have expected. But at the end of the day, Noah is still Noah and he made some tough shots down the stretch, providing a huge boost to the sputtering Cougs.
	Brandon Davies, C 3-7 FG | 0-0 3PT | 0-0 FT | 5 REB | 2 AST | 6 PTS Davies very well may be the most dominating post player in the WCC, but that doesn't matter much if he can't stay on the floor. He struggled with fouls early again Thursday, and played only 21 minutes as a result. (When he was in the game, Brandon tried his best Magic Johnson impression with mixed results. It was weird.) All in all, not his best game, but not a complete disaster either. Simply below par.

Report Card: BYU 79, Portland 60

Brigham Young Cougars

79

Final

60

Portland Pilots

STARTERS

	Matt Carlino, PG 3-11 FG | 0-4 3PT | 7-8 FT | 4 REB | 4 AST | 13 PTS The Cougars' shooting woes continued on Saturday, and Carlino was no exception. For some reason, Matt just can't find his stroke. Nevertheless, he continued to do a good job attacking the rim and got himself to the free throw line for easy points. He continues to commit lazy defensive lapses occasionally, but he's getting better on that end of the floor. All in all, not bad for an off night.
	Anson Winder, SG 0-2 FG | 0-2 3PT | 0-0 FT | 0 REB | 1 AST | 0 PTS Rose went with Winder at shooting guard for the second game in a row, but didn't get the same results. It's not that Anson did anything poorly, he was just a non-factor. He's not bringing anything stupendous to the table on offense and, against a mediocre team like Portland, his lock-down defensive abilities aren't as vital. It will be interesting to see if Rose sticks with him in the starting five next week.
	Charles Abouo, SF 1-6 FG | 1-4 3PT | 4-6 FT | 7 REB | 0 AST | 7 PTS Abouo spent a large amount of the game on the bench after picking up a multitude of stupid fouls. When he was actually on the floor, Charles brought great hustle and rebounding like he always does, but he also brought some really bad shot selection. The Cougars would benefit greatly from him making smarter choices on both sides of the ball.
	Noah Hartsock, PF 0-6 FG | 0-0 3PT | 12-12 FT | 4 REB | 0 AST | 12 PTS A weird night for Noah, who didn't make a field goal for the first time in... well, as long as I can remember. A lot of that had to do with him going to the bench early after picking up two quick fouls, and the rest had to do with him drawing a foul on pretty much every touch in the second half. Still, he made all 12 of his free throws and, as is the Hartsock way, took care of business when BYU needed him.
	Brandon Davies, C 7-13 FG | 0-0 3PT | 4-10 FT | 13 REB | 4 AST | 18 PTS A standout performance for Davies, who was literally all over the place. In addition to a strong offensive showing, Brandon also racked up 8 steals — a huge number by any standard, but unheard of for a big man. There's always room for improvement (he led the team in turnovers yet again and missed a boatload of free throws), but Brandon's excellent, balanced play was the driving force behind this win.

Report Card: BYU 83, Gonzaga 73

Brigham Young Cougars

83

Final

73

Gonzaga Bulldogs

STARTERS

	Matt Carlino, PG 7-13 FG | 1-2 3PT | 3-4 FT | 0 REB | 5 AST | 18 PTS This was Carlino's best game, hands down. This is the kind of game Rose wants him to play every time out. He was a floor general on offense and he pushed (or, more accurately, sprinted) the ball up the floor on every possession, which created scoring opportunities for himself and others. In a head-to-head with Gonzaga's celebrated freshman Kevin Pangos, Carlino won this round.
	Anson Winder, SG 4-8 FG | 1-4 3PT | 1-2 FT | 4 REB | 5 AST | 10 PTS This was the surprise move of the night, with Winder getting the start over Zylstra. Anson responded with a very solid effort. Though he looked a little sloppy handling the ball at times, he still put together a solid 10-4-5 game (somehow with no turnovers!), in addition to his invaluable lock-down defense. Here's to hoping he's rewarded with more opportunities in the future.
	Charles Abouo, SF 1-4 FG | 0-1 3PT | 2-2 FT | 1 REB | 1 AST | 2 PTS This was a tough one for Charles, mostly because he picked up a few quick fouls at the hands of the whistle-happy WCC refs and was taken out of the game — both figuratively and literally —from the very beginning. He never really got into rhythm on offense, but his defensive hounding of Pangos (at least when Abouo wasn't on the bench) was critical in keeping the freshman under-wraps.
	Noah Hartsock, PF 10-19 FG | 0-0 3PT | 4-5 FT | 14 REB | 3 AST | 24 PTS Noah may not look like much, but man is he good. After all the talk about which team had the superior post play, Hartsock answered the question emphatically tonight. After a tough shooting start, he heated up at the beginning of the second half and never looked back, leaving a pile of Zags along the way. A great performance from a great player in a huge game. What more can you ask?
	Brandon Davies, C 7-12 FG | 0-0 3PT | 1-3 FT | 5 REB | 1 AST | 15 PTS Davies also struggled with foul trouble throughout the game, but he made the most of his time on the floor. When he did get post touches, Brandon absolutely abused the Zags' Robert Sacre. He made him look downright silly, while also picking up his typical 2-3 charges for the night. A strong performance, especially considering the foul situation. Now if we could just figure out how to limit his turnovers...

Report Card: BYU 70, Virginia Tech 68

Brigham Young Cougars

70

Final

68

Virginia Tech Hokies

STARTERS

	Matt Carlino, PG 3-15 FG | 1-8 3PT | 0-0 FT | 6 REB | 5 AST | 7 PTS Don't look now, but this is becoming a thing. Carlino was offensively atrocious for his third consecutive game, shooting an abysmal 20 percent from the floor. Then again, no one else was making shots anyway, so Rose stuck with the freshman for 35 minutes — and credit Matt for staying focused, making smart plays, and stepping up to finally hit a couple key shots down the stretch.
	Brock Zylstra, SG 1-5 FG | 1-5 3PT | 0-0 FT | 0 REB | 2 AST | 3 PTS We need to be honest here: this was probably Zylstra's worst offensive game of the year. That being said, thanks be to everything good and holy that Brockzylla somehow wandered out of his personal shooting wilderness just long enough to drop the game-winning 3-pointer. Zylstra may have been largely irrelevant for his other 26 minutes on the floor, but he made that one count.
	Charles Abouo, SF 3-13 FG | 1-7 3PT | 2-2 FT | 8 REB | 2 AST | 9 PTS It's hard to understate how important Abouo is to this team. When he plays well, they excel. When he doesn't, they struggle. Charles didn't look so good in Blacksburg, but he managed to (briefly) put it together in a few key moments to sustain the Cougars' momentum. Also, he did an excellent job of locking down the wing and defending aggressively in the 2-3 zone. Kudos for that.
	Noah Hartsock, PF 7-12 FG | 1-1 3PT | 7-8 FT | 7 REB | 1 AST | 22 PTS Statistically, this may not have been Hartsock's best game, but it was certainly his biggest. With Davies in foul trouble, Noah put BYU on his back and practically took over the game for 5-6 minutes in the second half. It seemed like every time I turned around, he was either making a big shot or getting to the line. Oh, and did I mention his game-saving block on the last play? Indispensable.
	Brandon Davies, C 3-9 FG | 0-0 3PT | 11-12 FT | 5 REB | 4 AST | 17 PTS BYU probably won this game at the free throw line, and Davies' 12 attempts (and 11 makes!) were crucial. Brandon struggled a bit from the floor, but it didn't really matter. He made a living at the stripe and, had he stayed out of foul trouble, probably would have gone for 25-plus on the night. Also worth mentioning — his cross-court pass to Zylstra for the game-winner. Perfect.